Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | LIVENEWS | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
RugbyLeagueLive.com logo

Is South Sydney the worst NRL team ever?

 

Nick Markham | Rugbyleaguelive.com | 04/05/08 | 0

 

Souths' have a coach that no-one rates, are dead certainties to collect the wooden spoon, their forward pack has no ticker, and fellow NRL players avoid the club like the plague.

That's the opinion of the Rabbitohs NRL peers, according to a recent survey.

The survey of 100 current NRL players, published in The Sun Herald, paints winless South Sydney in the most unflattering of lights.

Similar surveys from varying sources are published throughout the NRL season, and most often cause some degree of controversy, but no side in recent memory has been the subject of such utter derision.

The Rabbitohs forward pack, filled predominantly by representative players including Roy Asotasi, David Kidwell, David Fa'alogo and John Sutton, is rated as the league's softest by 26 out of the 100 survey participants.

The next largest figure is the Warriors with eight, making the Bunnies an overwhelming selection for the league's weakest pack of forwards.

But it doesn't stop there.

Jason Taylor, a coach with an unblemished record when it comes his sides reaching the finals, is rated as coach no-one wants to play for by 19 percent of survey participants, out-polling even the much-maligned Brian Smith of Newcastle.

And the ultimate insult, 87 out of the 100 players polled were of the opinion that the bunnies had already booked themselves a one-way ticket to wooden-spoon territory.

Such results beg the question, Is South Sydney the worst NRL side ever ?

As always, your input is most welcome at rugbyleaguelive.com.

 
 
Make a Comment

Comments

4/05/2008 7:14:18 AM Um they certainly aren't the worst side EVER. Ever being the keyword. No one else has been champions as many times as souths. They haven't been great this season but give them some time. Anyway none of it really matters because I wouldn't trust the opinion of very many NRL players anyway. They are hardly known for their intelligence now are they. Posted by: Chris McCoy, Sydney, Australia Reply

5/05/2008 6:26:39 AM I think the may get 5-7 wins in the year. dont give them much hope to make the 8 need to win half ur games at least and have a healthy for and agasnt. cant see this happening. Posted by: michael , brisbane, Australia Reply

5/05/2008 9:56:08 AM get of jason taylors back hes a champion and always will be,great win souths good luck and keep smiling jason all us bears supporters respect you . Posted by: greg catt, asquith, Australia Reply

6/05/2008 7:52:06 AM Worst team ever? Please! After watching their performance v Cowboys on Sunday arvo I'm convinced they will NOT, and I repeat will not, get the wooden spoon this year. There are much worse teams with much worse playing rosters. You have the likes of Asotasi, Luke, Ndaira, Kidwell, Fa'alogo & Sutton and people are saying that Souths are the worst team ever? It's honestly ridiculous. Posted by: George Piller, Sydney, Australia Reply

16/05/2008 12:22:28 PM souths will bounce back.with the superstar at half back and george the 2nd at hooker i think you will find souths rocket up the ladder .yes i am a long time souths supporter. Posted by: greg catt, terranora, Australia Reply

 

Comment


 

 

 
 

 
 
500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.
 
 

* Required field

 

Send to friend


 

 

 

 

 

 
 
500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.
 

* Required field

 
 
 
CLOSE
 

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore.

New user?

 
 

Existing user?

Forgot your password?

CLOSE
 

Forgot your password?

Please enter the email address you registered with:

 

Back to login

 
You must have flash installed to view this site.
Feedback  |   Where to hear  |   Schedule

More Highlights

Highlights

Todd Carney is an imbecile and a grub

Badger sent off the wrong bloke: Andrew Moore

Best NRL team to watch? Canberra

CCT TV - Weekend Detention: Episode Five

Right idea, wrong execution Bulldogs


 
 
 
 
 
 

Your Say

When Steve Menzies plays his last game @ Brookvale in a few months he should be carried around the c... Steve Edwards, Narrabben, Australia on Steve Menzies signs with Bradford Bulls

who the *** are you melbourne ceo, nathan brown is 100% correct, stop trying to defend your club Josh Mattner, melbourne, Australia on 'He's childish': Storm hits back at Nathan Brown

I think Nathan Brown is a disgrace I dont want my kids to play Rugby league like that. Luke Rowthy, Canberra, Australia on Brown erupts over Melbourne's 'illegal tactics'

Where's Robert Finch on this and the Judiciary? They support cheating because it is 'good for the ga... Dave M, Sydney, Australia on Brown erupts over Melbourne's 'illegal tactics'

Onyah Brownee the first decent thing you've said. You are dead correct mate but dont hold your brea... tony blayney, illawong, Australia on Brown erupts over Melbourne's 'illegal tactics'

Good on you Browny!! Everyone see's this every week and we are all dead set sick of it. Its good to ... John T, Brookvale, Australia on Brown erupts over Melbourne's 'illegal tactics'

 
Most Commented
 
 
 
 

LATEST FEATURES

Stuart again forced to defend wayward skipper
Uninspiring Eels stay in finals race
Broncos too strong for dour Sharks
Smith sides with Brown
Round 20 Preview: Dragons v Bulldogs
Raiders flyer joins UK exodus